How to Fill Out AAA Form AR

AAA Form AR at a glance

What it is: New York Motor Vehicle No-Fault Insurance Law Arbitration Request Form: if you wish to arbitrate your claim, complete (print or type) all applicable sections of this form.

Who signs: Under Arbitration requested by, sign: Signature. Are you an attorney? Yes or No.

A filled-in AAA Form AR example: a medical bill in dispute

AAA Form AR example filled out, example: a medical bill in dispute
Dana Sample files a no-fault arbitration request for one medical bill. The clinic billed 850.00 and nothing was paid, so Other Necessary Expense(s) stays empty. The picture shows a filled Medical row, and every value in it is made up.

How to fill out AAA Form AR, box by box

Medical

AAA Form AR example filled out, medical

Under Part 3, Claim(s) in Dispute, place a check mark next to the space where appropriate. For Medical, if health benefit claims are in dispute, attach all bills in question (mark as "Exhibit A"), supporting documentation - reports, findings, narratives, etc. (mark as "Exhibit B"), assignment of benefits, if applicable (mark as "Exhibit C").

For each bill, enter the Doctor, hospital or other health provider, Amount of each bill, Amount paid, Unpaid or disputed balance, Dates of service, Date bill mailed, Was verification requested (No or Yes) and Date supplied.

If more space is needed, use AAA Form AR-Sup, on page 4 of this Form AR. Are additional bills on AAA Form AR-Sup? Yes or No.

Other Necessary Expense(s)

AAA Form AR example filled out, other Necessary Expense(s)

For Other Necessary Expense(s), attach bills in dispute as separate exhibit with supporting documentation - If more space is needed, use AAA Form AR-Sup, on page 4 of this Form AR. Enter the Type of expense claimed, Amount claimed, Amount in dispute, Date incurred and Date mailed.

Are additional expenses on AAA Form AR-Sup?

Denial and the reason the benefits should be paid

AAA Form AR example filled out, denial and the reason the benefits should be paid

Does this arbitration request include all issues known by the applicant/attorney to be in dispute with the insurer? If no, attach explanation.

Was a denial issued? If yes, attach a copy. If no, please explain on what basis claim was not paid.

Enter the reason you believe the denied or overdue benefits should be paid.

Arbitration requested by

AAA Form AR example filled out, arbitration requested by

Under Arbitration requested by, enter the Last name and First name, the Name of law firm, if any, Telephone number, Address, Email, the Date and the Fax number.

More rules for AAA Form AR

Optional No-Fault Arbitration is final and binding except for the limited grounds for review set forth in the law and regulations.

Upon receipt of this request, the American Arbitration Association will attempt to resolve the dispute by conciliation pursuant to Insurance Department Regulation 11 NYCRR 65-4.2 (b) (2) (iii). If the dispute cannot be resolved by conciliation, your case will be forwarded for arbitration.

For additional information please visit www.adr.org, and click on "New York No-Fault" in the right hand column.

This is AAA Form AR, Effective June 2004.

Pursuant to Insurance Department Regulation 11 NYCRR 65-4.2 (b) (3) (i), the applicant shall submit all supporting documentation with their request for arbitration. Submitted documentation must contain a table of contents and exhibits. The applicant must also simultaneously submit all documents to the insurer.

Following the original submission of documents, any other documents submitted by the applicant other than bills or claims for ongoing benefits will be marked "LATE SUBMISSION" and will be admitted into the record at the sole discretion of the arbitrator.

Pursuant to Insurance Department Regulation 11 NYCRR 65-4.5 (t) (1), the arbitrator may impose all administrative costs of arbitration to the applicant or apportion the administrative costs of arbitration between the parties if the arbitrator concludes that the applicant's arbitration request was frivolous, was without factual or legal merit or was filed for the purpose of harassing the respondent.

Under Part 1, Parties in Dispute, enter the Applicant for benefits: Last name, First name and Address, and Were benefits assigned to provider? Yes or No. For the Injured person, enter the Last name, First name and Address.

Enter the Date of accident. For the Policyholder, enter the Last name, First name and Address, then the Policy number.

For the Insurer or self-insurer, enter the Insurer's claims office address. For the Insurer's representative, enter the Telephone number and the Insurer claim or file number.

If bringing arbitration against MVAIC, provide the MVAIC claim number beginning with prefix "P", if available.

Did the accident occur in New York State? If no, is the injured person or a member of their household a New York State Automobile Policy Holder? The injured person was the Driver, Passenger, Pedestrian, Bicyclist or Other (Please explain).

Every attempt should be made to resolve this claim with the insurer prior to filing for arbitration. Enter when the insurer was last contacted and the name and title of the person contacted.

Written Submissions Arbitration: 11 NYCRR 65-4.5 (a) provides for arbitration on the basis of written submissions, at the discretion of the arbitrator, if the amount in dispute is less than $2,000 (checked November 10, 2026). Are you interested in having this case decided by the arbitrator entirely on the written submissions, without an in-person hearing? Are you interested in having a telephone hearing of this case, instead of an in-person hearing?

Priority Arbitration (90-day): 11 NYCRR 65-4.5 (i) (2) provides for Priority Arbitration in cases where the request for arbitration is made within 90 days after either a denial of claim was received or the claim became overdue, for EACH claim in dispute. A file that qualifies for Priority Arbitration is scheduled within 45 days from the date of transmittal from the conciliation center. Are you filing within 90 days after each claim in dispute was denied or became overdue?

Was the denial of claim based on late notice to the carrier? If yes, are you requesting Special Expedited Arbitration?

For Interest, enter Benefit paid late, Amount of bill, Date mailed to insurer, Was verification requested? (No or Yes), Date supplied and Date paid by insurer.

For Death Benefit, enter the Date death certificate mailed to insurer.

For Loss of Earnings, enter the Period in dispute: from and to, Gross earnings per month, Amount claimed and Date claim was made.

Attorney's Fee is one of the claims in dispute.

Totals: Any request in which total column is not completed will be returned.

Mail a duplicate copy of this entire filing including all attachments to the insurer against whom you are requesting arbitration and retain a copy for your records.

New York Motor Vehicle No-Fault Insurance Law Arbitration Request Form, Page 4: AAA Form AR-Sup - Supplemental Information for Part 3. Include Page 4 with your filing only if applicable.

Medical: Please continue from Part 3, Page 2.

Other Necessary Expenses: Please continue from Part 3, Page 2.

Common questions about AAA Form AR

Is there a deadline?

Special Expedited Arbitration (Late Notice): 11NYCRR 65-4.5 (b) provides for Special Expedited Arbitration proceedings for cases that were denied based on failure to submit notice of claim within 30 days after the accident. To qualify you must request Special Expedited Arbitration within 30 days after the mailing of the denial.

Where do I file it?

Mail the completed form and all requested attachments in duplicate to: American Arbitration Association, New York Insurance Case Management Center, 120 Broadway, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10271.

Are there fees?

The filing fee is $40.00, payable to the American Arbitration Association (checked November 10, 2026).

Is there a penalty?

Any person who knowingly and with intent to defraud any insurance company or other person files a statement of claim for any commercial or personal insurance benefits containing any materially false information commits a fraudulent insurance act, which is a crime, and shall also be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars and the value of the subject motor vehicle or stated claim for each violation.

What am I certifying when I sign?

The undersigned affirms and certifies as true under the penalty of perjury that this filing is being made in good faith and that upon information, belief and reasonable inquiry the documents being submitted herewith are not fraudulent and that exact copies of all documents provided herewith have been mailed to the insurer against whom the arbitration is being requested. Unless disclosed with this submission, the disputed amounts remain unpaid to the applicant by any payor and there has been no other filing of an arbitration request or lawsuit to resolve the disputed matters contained in this submission.

Sources

[1] AAA Form AR (Effective June 2004), New York Motor Vehicle No-Fault Insurance Law Arbitration Request Form (the Official source link on this page).

AAA Form AR PDF Details

The AAA Form AR, formally the New York Motor Vehicle No-Fault Insurance Law Arbitration Request Form, is used by claimants who choose arbitration to resolve insurance disputes outside of court. It requires complete details about all parties: the applicant, the insurance provider, and the specifics of the claim being disputed.

A wide range of disputes can be arbitrated using this form, including medical bills, other necessary expenses, loss of earnings, and death benefits. Expedited or priority arbitration is available for urgent cases. Before arbitration begins, the AAA encourages conciliation between parties to seek a voluntary settlement. For related arbitration documents, see the AAA subpoena form or the arbitration UM form.

Filing accuracy is critical: the arbitration outcome is binding and may only be appealed on very limited grounds under applicable law. Claims found frivolous or without merit may result in arbitration costs being imposed on the applicant. Ensure all supporting documentation is complete and attached before submission.

QuestionAnswer
Form NameAaa Form Ar
Form Length4 pages
Fillable?No
Fillable fields0
Avg. time to fill out1 min
Other namesMVAIC, 2004, ar 1 form, form ar1