Baseball Skills Assessment at a glance
What it is: Baseball Skills Assessment Form: coaches score each player according to the listed categories of skills.
This standardized format may be used for all outdoor baseball tryouts, to evaluate players for All-Star travel teams or for draft purposes within “house” leagues.
A filled-in Baseball Skills Assessment example: a coach scores one player

How to fill out Baseball Skills Assessment, box by box
Scoring on the five point scale
The evaluation form uses a five point scale to measure the various skills.
A score of five (5) points should be awarded for any skill which the player demonstrates an exceptional level of ability relative to his peers.
A score of one (1) point should be awarded for any skill which the player demonstrates an extremely poor level of ability relative to his peers.
Score two, three or four points for levels of skill in-between the two extremes.
Select the team from the scores
So that the All-Star selection process is fair to all players, the evaluators should use the quantitative scores to select the first eight (8) players on the team.
The All-Star manager would then select the final four (or more) positions on the team using any criteria he sees fit.
Managers can weight the categories according to their thoughts as to what makes a good team.
Using the overall score in each of the following defensive categories: infield, outfield, throwing, and catching, there are a maximum of 20 points.
For the hitting skills, coaches should count mechanics, power and contact for a maximum hitting total of 15 points.
Coaches should add 1 or 2 points to the players with the fastest times during the base running assessment and deduct 1 or 2 points to the slowest players.
Coaches may award or deduct points based on a player's demonstrated attitude, focus and hustle.
Coaches may wish to add between 1 and 5 points for pitching or catching skills.
More rules for Baseball Skills Assessment
Everyone should plan on the tryouts taking between 2 and 2.5 hours to complete.
Give each player 5 to 8 good pitches.
Have pitchers throw approximately 5 pitches. Catchers should catch at least two pitchers.
Sources
[1] Baseball Skills Assessment (Rev. February 2006) (the served file; no issuer file found) (the Official source link on this page).


