Form 623-1A at a glance
What it is: Form 623-1A is the Georgia State Defense Force Performance Evaluation form.
Who signs: Under RATING OFFICIAL (OIC / NOIC), REVIEWING OFFICIAL (BDE / UNIT COMMANDER) and RATED INDIVIDUAL, sign on SIGNATURE and fill in DATE.
A filled-in Form 623-1A example: a rater fills in the heading of a performance evaluation

How to fill out Form 623-1A, box by box
Rated individual, unit, position and period
Rating official, reviewing official and rated individual

Under RATING OFFICIAL (OIC / NOIC), write COMMENTS, fill in NAME, RANK and TITLE, then sign on SIGNATURE and fill in DATE.
Under REVIEWING OFFICIAL (BDE / UNIT COMMANDER), mark CONCUR or NON-CONCUR, write COMMENTS, fill in NAME, RANK and TITLE, then sign on SIGNATURE and fill in DATE.
Under RATED INDIVIDUAL, write COMMENTS, then sign on SIGNATURE and fill in DATE.
More rules for Form 623-1A
INSTRUCTIONS: Comments must be based on performance and potential based on that performance. Promotion recommendations are prohibited. Do not consider previous promotion recommendations, family activities, marital status, race, sex, ethnic origin, age or religion. RATER: Focus your evaluation on what the individual did, how well he/she did it, and how the individual contributed to the mission. Write in "concise" bullet format. REVIEWER: If you disagree, you may ask the Rater to review the evaluation. You may not direct a change in the evaluation. Mark "Non-Concur" and explain.
For Position Knowledge, mark 1, 2 or 3 for knowledge, skill and ability to effectively and efficiently perform all position tasks.
For Leadership Skills, mark 1, 2 or 3.
For Communications Skills, mark 1, 2 or 3: Listens, speaks, presents, and writes effectively.
For Organizational Skills, mark 1, 2 or 3.
For Responsibility & Accountability, mark 1, 2 or 3.
For Motivation, mark 1, 2 or 3.
For Judgment and Decision-Making, mark 1, 2 or 3.
On page 1, for Drill Attendance, enter the number of drills attended and mark 1, 2 or 3: Exceeds = 10-12 drills + extra duty assignments; Meets = 10-12 drills; Below = Less than 10 drills.
For Annual Training, mark Yes or No: Attended and participated in Annual Training.
For Values, mark Yes or No.
For Military Bearing & Fitness, mark Yes or No.
For Personal Development, mark Yes or No.
For the OVERALL EVALUATION, mark 1, 2 or 3.
Write a BRIEF SUMMARY OF NEW GOALS & OBJECTIVES.
Sources
[1] GSDF Form 623-1A (Rev. JUL 2004), Georgia State Defense Force Performance Evaluation (served file, no issuer file found) (the Official source link on this page).

