Peer Review Feedback Form PDF Details

Engaging in peer review sessions using the CARES Peer Review Feedback Form is an invaluable step toward honing the skill of producing logical, readable drafts. This process proves beneficial for both the writer, who gains insight into the effectiveness of their communication with diverse readerships, and the reviewer, who enhances critical writing and reading abilities. The guiding philosophy of the form is centered around constructive criticism, urging participants to focus first on Higher Order Concerns like thesis, audience, purpose, and organization before delving into Lower Order Concerns such as grammar and punctuation. It emphasizes the importance of providing feedback that transcends the unhelpful "It looks good to me" to include specific, actionable advice. The form facilitates a structured dialogue between the writer and reviewer, detailing aspects done well, pinpointing confusing parts along with clarifying questions, soliciting additional information to support the thesis, evaluating the relevance of details to the essay's argument, and summarizing new insights gained. This structured approach not only aids in the revision of current drafts but also instills a robust framework for critical analysis and feedback that writers and reviewers can carry forward into future projects.

QuestionAnswer
Form NamePeer Review Feedback Form
Form Length2 pages
Fillable?Yes
Fillable fields8
Avg. time to fill out30 sec
Other namesfeedback review forms, cares feedback form, cares peer review feedback form, cares peer review

How to Fill Out Peer Review Feedback Form

Peer Review Feedback Form at a glance

What it is: Peer Review Feedback Form: a peer review session is effective for both the writer and the reviewer.

A filled-in Peer Review Feedback Form example: a student reviews a classmate's essay

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, example: a student reviews a classmate's essay
A student reviewer fills out the feedback form for a classmate's essay. The reviewer lists strengths and the thesis, then gives three suggestions for revising one unclear paragraph. The picture shows every box filled, and every value in it is made up.

How to fill out Peer Review Feedback Form, box by box

Writer and Reviewer

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, writer and Reviewer

Fill in the Writer and the Reviewer.

Congratulate

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, congratulate

Under What does the writer do well in this assignment? (List one or more aspects.) Also, please write the writer's main claim or focus (thesis) according to what you have read. (It may not be the last sentence of the first paragraph - the traditional place for the thesis.)

Ask clarifying questions

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, ask clarifying questions

Say what part(s) of the essay were a bit confusing, and why.

Under What parts of the essay were a bit confusing, Why, What specific suggestions (3 or fewer) do you have for revising the unclear parts of this writing, write 3 or fewer specific suggestions.

For ideas, you may use the list: the thesis needs to better identify the main point of the essay; the topic sentence(s) need to identify the main point of the paragraph; sources, if used, need to be clearly identified.

Request more

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, request more

Write what you would like to know more about the topic that can enhance the essay and that supports the thesis.

Evaluate its value

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, evaluate its value

Under What specific detail(s) do not work with the essay, write the specific details that do not work with the essay (e.g. doesn't support the thesis) or can be moved within the essay.

Summarize

Peer Review Feedback Form example filled out, summarize

Write overall what new information you have learned or how you are thinking differently after this reading.

More rules for Peer Review Feedback Form

First attend to Higher Order Concerns: thesis, audience, purpose, organization, development (support). Then attend to Lower Order Concerns: sentence structure, punctuation, word choice, spelling.

The least helpful comment to receive from a peer reviewer is "It looks good to me."

Sources

[1] CARES Peer Review Feedback Form, Excelsior University (the Official source link on this page).